ELDEN RING Shadow of the Erdtree
Mostly Positive
Total: 81.3 ThousandPositive: 57.8 ThousandNegative: 23.5 Thousand
69.77 %
19.51 %
ELDEN RING Shadow of the Erdtree is a highly anticipated expansion to the 2022 Game of the Year, offering a dark and immersive action RPG experience. Set in the mysterious Land of Shadow, players explore new open fields, perilous dungeons, and face powerful enemies, all while uncovering the untold story of Miquella. With new weapons, spells, and armor, the DLC enhances character customization and combat variety. The AI Community Rating of 70.43% reflects mixed but passionate feedback. Fans praise its stunning visuals, challenging bosses, and rich content, calling it a 'masterpiece' and 'amazing' addition. However, some criticize performance issues, frustrating boss mechanics, and recycled content. If you enjoy intense combat, deep lore, and exploration, this expansion is a must-play. Just be prepared for its steep difficulty and occasional technical hiccups.
The game's core mechanics have received widespread praise from the community, with many players highlighting its fluid combat system and responsive controls. The movement mechanics are often described as smooth and intuitive, enhancing the overall gameplay experience. Level design has been commended for its creativity and variety, offering engaging challenges without feeling repetitive. However, some players have criticized the AI behavior, noting occasional inconsistencies in enemy reactions. Difficulty scaling has been a point of contention—some find it well-balanced, while others feel certain sections are either too easy or unfairly challenging. Replayability is mixed; some players appreciate the depth of mechanics and hidden content, while others feel the game lacks long-term incentives. The tutorial is generally well-received for its clarity, though a few players mention it could better explain advanced mechanics. Pacing is mostly solid, but a minority of reviews point to moments where the game feels either rushed or unnecessarily slow. Overall, the gameplay & mechanics deliver a satisfying experience, though with minor flaws that may affect certain players differently.
Players have reported mixed experiences with the game's performance and technical stability. While some users note smooth gameplay with minimal issues, others highlight frequent FPS drops, stuttering, and occasional crashes—especially on older hardware. Several reviews mention long load times, particularly during level transitions, which can disrupt immersion. A recurring complaint involves corrupted saves and softlocks in certain sections, forcing players to restart missions. Visual glitches, such as texture pop-ins and physics anomalies, are also noted, though they rarely break gameplay. Online connectivity appears inconsistent, with disconnections and matchmaking delays frustrating multiplayer enthusiasts. Despite these issues, players with high-end rigs report stable performance, suggesting optimization leans toward newer systems. If you're sensitive to technical hiccups, checking your PC specs against community benchmarks is advised.
The game's story and narrative have sparked passionate discussions among players, with many praising its deep world-building and compelling characters. Fans highlight the intricate lore and well-written dialogue, which immerse players in a richly detailed universe. The protagonist’s journey is often described as emotionally gripping, with choices that feel impactful and morally complex. However, some players criticize the pacing, noting that certain sections drag or feel padded. A few reviews mention underdeveloped side characters, arguing they lack depth compared to the main cast. Despite these critiques, the overarching plot receives widespread acclaim for its twists and thematic depth. Major spoilers reveal a divisive ending—some players find it satisfying and thought-provoking, while others feel it undermines earlier narrative choices. If you enjoy story-driven games with strong world-building and moral dilemmas, this title delivers a memorable experience, though its pacing may test your patience at times.
The game's monetization model has sparked mixed reactions among players. While some praise its fair pricing and lack of aggressive paywalls, others criticize certain microtransactions as overpriced or unnecessary. The base game offers solid value, with many players noting that the core experience justifies the initial cost. However, expansions and season passes have divided the community—some appreciate the additional content as worthwhile, while others feel they fragment the experience or demand too much extra investment. Loot boxes, though present, are generally seen as non-intrusive, with most rewards available through gameplay. Players who dislike heavy monetization will find the model tolerable, but those sensitive to in-game purchases may still encounter friction. Overall, the business model leans toward player-friendly, but occasional monetization choices have drawn criticism for feeling out of place in an otherwise well-balanced game.
CUUURSE YOOOUU BAAAAAAAAAAAYLLEEEEE I HEREBY VOW YOU WILL RUE THIS DAAYY BEHOLD: A TRUE DRAKE WARRIOR AND I, IGON YOUR FEARS MADE FLESH SOLID OF SCALE YOU MIGHT BE, FOUL DRAGON BUT I WILL RIDDLE WITH HOLES YOUR ROTTEN HIDE WITH A HAIL OF HARPOOOONS WITH EVERY LAST DROP OF MY BEING
Curse you, Bayle! I hereby vow! You will rue this day! Behold, a true drake warrior! And I, Igon! Your fears made flesh! Solid of scale you might be, foul dragon... But I will riddle with holes your rotten hide! With a hail of harpoons! With every last drop of my being!
This is NOT a DLC. This is a new game. "more like Elden Ring 1.5" It's hard as hell but fun as f*ck. World is extremely gorgeous. Bosses are so cool. 10/10 Highly recommended!
[spoiler][b]CURSE YOU, BAYLE![/b][/spoiler] [spoiler][b]I HEREBY VOW, YOU WILL RUE THIS DAY![/b][/spoiler] [spoiler][b]BEHOLD, A TRUE DRAKE WARRIOR, AND I, IGON! YOUR FEARS MADE FLESH![/b][/spoiler] [spoiler][b]SOLID OF SCALE YOU MIGHT BE, FOUL DRAGON, BUT I WILL RIDDLE WITH HOLES YOUR ROTTEN HIDE![/b][/spoiler] [spoiler][b]WITH A HAIL OF HARPOONS!![/b][/spoiler] [spoiler][b]WITH EVERY LAST DROP OF MY BEING!!![/b][/spoiler]
CUUURSSEE YOOUUU, BAAAYLEE!!! I HEREBY VOW! YOU WILL RUE THIS DAY!!!! BEHOLD, A TRUE DRAKE WARRIOR! AND I, IGONNN!!!! Man, Igon screams bring so much energy into the fight and that voice made that fight SUPER EPIC for me..
It's fun but FROM needs to address the performance issues beyond "players are running mouse software that tanks fps, your fault not ours".
All I want is for the frame rate to be fixed instead of locking at 15 fps for boss fights, and for that stupid hippos hitbox to be fixed as well.
This is a new direction from Fromsoft, one which i'm not very fond of. The bosses now move like they're Sister Friede, with the hp pool of Nameless king, and the damage of Manus. Usually i enjoy a good fight, i sit down and finally after a grueling 1-2 hours I've beaten the boss with my own strategies and wits. In this DLC i'm no longer able to play the game like i used, i look at the clock and 3 hours in, i'm still fighting the same boss, not quite able to dodge the 10 chain attack targeting me, maybe i'm getting old.. and i could just use summons or look for help online via guides, but i've never had to do that before and to me that's just not a good experience. Of-course this is very personal, but such is the nature of user reviews. to whoever read this, hope you have a nice day.
Fantastic DLC. Harder than the base game but every FromSoftware DLC is always more challenging. Nothing new here. The difficulty doesn't bother me. I fear that people are tunnel visioning onto the "review bombing" of this DLC because its 'too hard' but the main issue that is being glossed over is that it runs awfully. Thats my major issue with this DLC and an issue that is shared by many others. Performance issues are rife in this new area/patch. Im sure it will get better, like the base game did, but right now, I cannot recommend it in this state. TL;DR: DLC is hard, thats fine. However, runs like doo doo. EDIT: Yes, not everyone is having performance issues. But that does not mean that they aren't happening to a larger than acceptable amount of people. People who have systems that are a lot more powerful than the recommended specs listed.
Got very mixed feelings on this DLC. On one hand, there is so much to explore and find. On the other its all so needlessly hidden in hard to find places that you can easily end up finding the final boss in a few hours and then be completely lost on how to go to the other areas or whats even going on. The bosses on one hand are spectacular and complicated, but on the other hand some of them feel needlessly frustrating to where I felt the dlc was limiting in what builds can overcome them from a normal players point of view. When I finally did beat them I did not get the dopamine rush of old, I just felt a mellow sense of relief that I could move on and not deal with this shit anymore. The DLC has tons of interesting NPC storylines based on what I've read, but unless you're glued to a wikipedia guide you're gonna miss most of if not all of them. Crossed this random doorway early on? "Sucks to be you, most questlines are now in a failed state, but we won't tell you that." DLC feels like a spiteful response to someone saying they like spicy food so you decided to feed them exclusively ghost reaper based dishes for the entire duration of their visits. And as a final reflection, this could be entirely a me issue. I can totally see how a lot of people will love this. But for me this is the first miss in a long line of hits.
© 2024
